I recently visited a CPA in Indianapolis. He was a donor to The Salvation Army who had given for many years at a modest level. All of a sudden, he made a very large gift. When I found out about it, I was fortunate enough to secure an appointment with him. I was curious to see if I could engage him and build a relationship with him over time.
As I met with him in his office, he was warm and engaging. He was thankful that the tax season was finally winding down. He was looking forward to improving his golf game. I asked him what caused him to make such a wonderful, increased gift in 2012. He said he sold an asset and gave the proceeds to four charities in equal shares, including The Salvation Army.
I then really began to get curious. I asked him if he enjoyed my visit. He said he enjoyed it very much. I asked him if the other three charities contacted him in the same manner. He noted that not only did they contact him, but he and his wife went out to dinner with the president of one organization, visited another organization and met other representatives at the third organization. Instead of feeling very competitive and jealous with my juices flowing, I felt a sense of pride for my profession. I personally knew my other peers who visited him, and I was glad all were engaging him. I do not usually have the opportunity to discover this type of information from a donor.
The moral of this story is obvious. In Indianapolis, like other places across the United States, the competition for the charitable dollar is very keen. The good news from this experience is that fundraising professionals are making their involvement positive to the prospect and donor. In this case, the donor laughed and said he was happy to be so popular. He loved the attention from the four charities. If we truly care about those we serve, we realize quickly it is not about us individually but about our profession as a whole. We need to promote philanthropy and understand prospects have a wide range of choices, and many donors contribute to several charities at the same time. You have to share and be happy with your piece of the pie. It is all about promoting philanthropy!
To take this lesson to another level, I am currently building a major-gifts program, and one of my volunteer leaders is also working in a leadership role with another charity. He likes both charities equally. I have high regard for my counterpart at the other charity, and we have actually attended functions together at the request of the volunteer leader. We both do not mind at all. We both strive to exceed expectations with him. In fact, I am honored to work with both men. I know this happens with all of you every day, whether you know it or not. This is what makes the nonprofit arena special and unique.
I am so proud to work in a community of friends!
- Companies:
- Salvation Army
Duke Haddad, Ed.D., CFRE, is currently the divisional associate executive director of development for The Salvation Army Indiana Division. He specializes in corporate development and capital campaigns. When time allows, he serves as president of Duke Haddad and Associates LLC and as a freelance educator for various educational entities.
He has contributed more than 600 articles to NonProfit PRO since 2008.
He earned his doctorate degree from West Virginia University, with an emphasis in education administration and a dissertation on donor characteristics. He also holds a master’s degree from Marshall University, with an emphasis on public administration and a thesis on annual fund program analysis. He received his bachelor’s degree, cum laude, in marketing and management from West Virginia University.
Duke has received the Fundraising Executive of the Year Award from the Association of Fundraising Professionals Indiana Chapter. He also has been honored with the Outstanding West Virginian Award, the Kentucky Colonel Award, and theSagamore of the Wabash Award from the governors of West Virginia, Kentucky, and Indiana, respectively, for his many career contributions to the field of philanthropy. He has been an AFP member for more than 40 years and has held the Certified Fund Executive (CFRE) designation for more than 30 years.
This year, Duke was named to Marquis Who’s Who in America for 2026-2027 and as an International CFRE Ambassador. He also recently published the book, "Prescriptions Rx for Nonprofit Success," which features more than 30 previously published articles, including several from NonProfit PRO.





