Data Transparency: Are You a Frog in Hot Water?
I’ve written close to 100 blog posts and I have never actually taken someone else’s blog and copied it word for word—but this article from Lisa Scott at Barker & Scott is so perfect and spot-on I just want to share it verbatim. You all know from my other blogs how important I believe data is to our success in the nonprofit industry. But, it is not enough to just say “data"—it’s about data strategies, business rules, organizational priorities and much more when you think through your data.
Here’s what Lisa thinks—and I could not agree more. From Lisa Scott, executive at Barker & Scott:
There’s an old anecdote about frogs placed in gradually heated water not recognizing danger until it is too late. It’s often used as a metaphor for people ignoring, say, the growing rumblings of a nearby volcano, steadily melting Arctic ice or, in this case, changing consumer experiences and expectations when it comes to their brand relationships.
Let's be blunt: Like the rest of us, nonprofit leaders have come to expect highly personalized, concierge-style treatment from their favorite commercial brands. Yet when it comes to their own policies and procedures, their constituents and supporters shouldn't expect that same level of treatment. That’s bad news for an industry that wants to attract, retain and often monetize a public grown accustomed to customer-friendly practices.
Consider the experience you or I have come to expect from most commercial brands. We may be influenced by a friend’s comment on social media, investigate the recommended brand’s website, sign up for a newsletter, receive a special offer, download that offer on our mobile phone, then redeem it at a retail location. Yet despite the complexity of that multichannel journey, we expect to be recognized at every step of that engagement. A failure to do so could lead to alienation or loss of the customer in a marketplace where such expectations are now commonplace. And where does all of this behind-the-scenes magic take place? With data sharing. Silos are torn down, internal goals, measurements and personnel policies redefined, and individual customer channels and touchpoints made subordinate to the overall customer experience.
Contrast this experience—the one you and I experience countless times a year—with the way the nonprofit industry still treats its supporters. Data is hoarded and safeguarded even within the same walls, and especially across chapters and affiliates. Organizational metrics and operating silos remain stubbornly resistant to change, meaning one hand of the organization rarely knows what the other is doing. And in the case of large nonprofits, we’re talking about a lot of hands. So why, when the rest of the corporate world recognizes the imperative for data sharing and transparency, is the nonprofit world falling farther behind? In a word, fear. Fear borne out of outdated policies and philosophies that still regard supporter data as the province of whoever collects it first. Meaning that data and channels are deemed more important than the supporter's experience!
For obvious reasons we’re treading into dangerous waters with a public accustomed to a far different level of brand engagement. Take the coveted snowbirder, that deep-pocketed donor with the wherewithal not simply to flee colder winter climes, but also to donate to national nonprofits and chapters alike. Except that because the chapter and national offices refuse to share that supporter’s data, he’s treated like a stranger by the very same organization to which he recently donated $50,000. We're talking dead frog here. Smaller and far more common examples of this occur countless times a day across the nonprofit industry.
Fortunately, with a few changes that frog not only can be saved but turned into a prince (or at least princely treatment of your supporters). For comparison purposes, it’s worth noting that the commercial brands that have transitioned from channel-centric to customer-centric marketing are going gangbusters. Why? Because they have a wealth of information about each customer that is shared across channels, meaning they can continually refine and improve upon the treatment of that customer—the content, the offers, the asks—with a strong (data-driven) idea of his/her response. Meanwhile, marketers and other stakeholders can work more strategically to nurture and expand that customer relationship in ways that benefit the entire organization.
So how does the nonprofit industry transition to this same supporter-friendly model of operations?
- Face the fear and forge a top-down commitment to gradually transition toward customer-centric policies
- Tear down operating silos and institute policies embracing data transparency
- Put in place new forms of employee recognition and reward that value enterprise-wide results as a product of multichannel efforts
- Implement centralized data warehouses that integrate supporter data as a single organizational asset
Happily, this is not an issue of technology. Many, if not most, of today’s major nonprofit data management systems are capable of embracing a supporter-centric operating model. The key is to develop the will to do it. The alternative is to find yourself in hotter water.
This post originally appeared here. It was reprinted with the author's permission.
Vice President, Strategy & Development
Eleventy Marketing Group
Angie is ridiculously passionate about EVERYTHING she’s involved in — including the future and success of our nonprofit industry.
Angie is a senior exec with 25 years of experience in direct and relationship marketing. She is a C-suite consultant with experience over the years at both nonprofits and agencies. She currently leads strategy and development for marketing intelligence agency Eleventy Marketing Group. Previously she has worked at the innovative startup DonorVoice and as general manager of Merkle’s Nonprofit Group, as well as serving as that firm’s CRM officer charged with driving change within the industry. She also spent more 14 years leading the marketing, fundraising and CRM areas for two nationwide charities, The Arthritis Foundation and the American Cancer Society. Angie is a thought leader in the industry and is frequent speaker at events, and author of articles and whitepapers on the nonprofit industry. She also has received recognition for innovation and influence over the years.